01•Economy•GS-3
Social Issues + Economy + Environment & Ecology
Why in news
The Tribal Council of Great and Little Nicobar has raised concerns over alleged remarks that the Shompen should adopt a “modern lifestyle” in the context of the Great Nicobar Island (GNI) Project. The issue highlights tensions between infrastructure development, tribal rights and conservation. Shompen: An indigenous Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group (PVTG) inhabiting Great Nicobar Island.
Prelims focus
Key factual points
- The Tribal Council of Great and Little Nicobar has raised concerns over alleged remarks that the Shompen should adopt a “modern lifestyle” in the context of the Great Nicobar Island (GNI) Project.
- The issue highlights tensions between infrastructure development, tribal rights and conservation.
- Shompen: An indigenous Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group (PVTG) inhabiting Great Nicobar Island.
- Traditionally follow a largely hunter-gatherer and forest-dependent lifestyle.
- They have relatively limited interaction with the outside world, making disease exposure and cultural disruption important concerns.
- Great Nicobar: Part of the Nicobar Islands, located close to major Indian Ocean–Malacca Strait sea routes.
- The GNI Project envisages major infrastructure including an International Container Transshipment Terminal at Galathea Bay, airport, power facilities and township.
- The project has generated debate over forest diversion, biodiversity, tribal reserves and indigenous rights.
- The Andaman and Nicobar Protection of Aboriginal Tribes Regulation, 1956 provides a framework for protecting indigenous communities and regulating access to tribal areas.
- PVTG protection → tribal autonomy → development-induced ecological/social impacts → sustainable development.
- Prelims Trap: Shompen are associated with Great Nicobar, not the Andaman Islands.
- Green India Mission: CAG Flags Implementation Gaps
Prelims traps
- Distinguish the immediate development from the permanent mandate or structure of the institution concerned.
- Revise exact names, dates, locations and legal or institutional terms from the source points; do not infer facts not stated there.
Mains analysis
Background and key dimensions
- They have relatively limited interaction with the outside world, making disease exposure and cultural disruption important concerns.
- Great Nicobar: Part of the Nicobar Islands, located close to major Indian Ocean–Malacca Strait sea routes.
- The GNI Project envisages major infrastructure including an International Container Transshipment Terminal at Galathea Bay, airport, power facilities and township.
- The project has generated debate over forest diversion, biodiversity, tribal reserves and indigenous rights.
- The Andaman and Nicobar Protection of Aboriginal Tribes Regulation, 1956 provides a framework for protecting indigenous communities and regulating access to tribal areas.
- PVTG protection → tribal autonomy → development-induced ecological/social impacts → sustainable development.
- Prelims Trap: Shompen are associated with Great Nicobar, not the Andaman Islands.
- Green India Mission: CAG Flags Implementation Gaps
- The Himachal Pradesh Forest Department is preparing FIRs over the alleged use of glyphosate to clear vegetation for pea cultivation on forest land in Mandi district.
- Officials have destroyed illegally cultivated crops and warned that glyphosate use may affect forest soil and nearby water sources.
- A broad-spectrum, systemic herbicide used primarily to control weeds.
- It inhibits the shikimate pathway, an important biochemical pathway in plants and some microorganisms.
Analytical use
- Connect the development with its institutional, policy, economic, social, environmental or security implications only where supported above.
- In a Mains answer, separate the verified development from broader evaluation and use the named evidence precisely.
Way forward
- Base recommendations on the gaps and institutional responsibilities identified in the source-grounded points.